Harrison Bergeron - Character Diary Entries

Based upon today's reading, choose Hazel or George and compose a character diary entry.  You entry should be AT LEAST a complete paragraph (5-8 sentences) and create AT LEAST one identifiable tone.
Tone Examples:
  Positive Tones - Relaxed, Hopeful, Optimistic, Content, Calm
  Negative Tones - Irritated, Uninterested, Pessimistic, Disappointed, Indignant

Collectivism

Choose one of the following statements that you most closely agree with.  Explain why you agree with that chosen statement. You MAY NOT use "I feel," "I think," "I believe," "In my opinion," "I agree," or "I disagree," in your response.  In order to receive full credit, your response must 

 1) be at least five to seven sentences, 

 2) use the words CONFORM and INDIVIDUAL, and 

 3) contain one outside quote that supports your reasoning.

QUOTE #1 - We are discreet sheep; we wait to see how the drove is going, and then go with the drove.

QUOTE #2 - It is our nature to conform; it is a force which not many can successfully resist.  What is its seat? The inborn requirement of self-approval.

Antigone - Stubborn or Determined?

ANTIGONE AND ISMENE

Are Antigone and Ismene stubborn and arrogant, or do they exhibit a reasonable degree of determination? Support your response with evidence from the play.

REMINDERS: 

1. Answer the question in a complete sentence.

2. Give textual evidence to support your answer.

     - Quotation marks indicate you have quoted directly from 
        the text.

     - All responses should include a lead-in.

        Example:  In the play it states, "..."

                           Antigone says, "..."

                           Ismene states, "..."

3. Incorporate comments to tie your answer and evidence together.  Your comments should not restate your answer.  

    - This shows... (Optional sentence starter)

Transcendentalist Era - Conformity vs. Nonconformity

NONCONFORMITY VS. CONFORMITY

NONCONFORMITY STATEMENT– Following the herd (often to the slaughter house) is dangerous! You have to have the free thinkers! Society's ways do not fit for everybody.

CONFORMITY STATEMENT– The “society” is the system set up to benefit the masses over the individual...so going against that is, of course, dangerous to the masses.

ASSIGNMENT:  CHOOSE ONE OF THE STATEMENTS ABOVE THAT YOU MOST CLOSELY AGREE WITH.  EXPLAIN WHY YOU AGREE WITH THAT CHOSEN STATEMENT.  THEN, CHOOSE ONE OF THE FOLLOWING QUOTES BELOW TO SUPPORT YOUR REASONING AND TIE THEM TOGETHER.  YOU MAY NOT USE “I FEEL,” “I THINK,” “I BELIEVE,” "IN MY OPINION," “I AGREE” OR “I DISAGREE” IN YOUR RESPONSE.  IN ORDER TO RECEIVE FULL CREDIT, YOUR RESPONSE MUST BE AT LEAST FIVE TO SEVEN SENTENCES LONG AND CONTAIN ONE OF THE GIVEN QUOTES AND SUPPORTING COMMENTS.

NONCONFORMITY QUOTES

“You don't get harmony when everybody sings the same note.”

-Doug Floyd

“Conformity is the jailer of freedom and the enemy of growth.”

-John Fitzgerald Kennedy

“Progress is impossible without change, and those who cannot change their minds cannot change anything.”

- George Bernard Shaw

CONFORMITY QUOTES

“Conformity, humility, acceptance...with these coins we are to pay our fares to paradise.”

-Robert Lindner

“The opposite of bravery is not cowardice but conformity.”

-Dr. Robert Anthony 

“No man on earth is truly free, all are slaves of money or necessity. Public opinion or fear of prosecution forces each one, against his conscience, to conform.”

-Euripides

EXAMPLE:

The “society” is the system set up to benefit the masses over the individual...so going against that is, of course, dangerous to the masses.  Even though being an individual is an important Transcendentalist belief, in reality, the system that society has set up is designed to prevent mass chaos and is based upon the group and not the individual. In America we have a democratic system which allows Americans the right to vote, and through this process majority rules.  Everyone does not always win.  Sometimes conformity or compromise is important in keeping order.  Martin Luther King Jr. and Gandhi went against society, but they still conformed to the laws and rules of society in order to get what they wanted.  In order to keep the masses safe they chose to operate within the system set up.  Robert Lindner said it best when he stated, “Conformity, humility, acceptance...with these coins we are to pay our fares to paradise.”  Both of these great men exhibited some form of conformity  and humility and those two things made them accepted individuals which has afforded many Americans "paradise" here on Earth.

Masks

 
Please Hear What I Am Not Saying

By Charles C. Finn

Don't be fooled by me.
Don't be fooled by this mask that I wear.
For I wear a thousand masks and none of them are really me.
Masks that I'm too afraid to take off, fearing that you'll get to know me.
Pretending is an art that is second nature to me.
I'm pretending that I am in command and that I need no one.
That I'm cool and that my surface is so smooth and I cannot be shaken by anything.
I act as if I am in control, but please don't for one moment be fooled by my surface, that's only
my mask.
Beneath this mask lies no smugness, no complacence.
Beneath this mask dwells the real me in confusion, loneliness, and fear.
But I don't dare tell you that.
I don't dare tell you that this is my mask.
I'm frightened by all the possibilities of my weaknesses being exposed.

I think about it all the time. Will I look like a fool?
That's why I work frantically to create this mask to hide behind in my relationship with people.
This nonchalant, sophisticated facade helps me pretend and shields me from the glance that knows
me.
But such a glance is precisely my only salvation.
It's my only salvation if, however, the glance is followed by  acceptance and love.
It's the only thing that can liberate me from myself, from my own self-built prison...from the
barriers that I have so  painstakingly created.
It is only that glance that will assure me of what I cannot assure in myself and, that is, that I
am really worth something.

But I don't tell you this. I don't dare to. I'm afraid to.  I'm afraid that your glance will not be
followed by acceptance and love.
I'm afraid that you'll think less of me...that you'll laugh and that your laugh would kill me.
I'm afraid that deep-down I am nothing. That I'm just no good and soon you're going to find out and
you'll no longer love me...that you'll reject me.
So I play my game. My desperate, pretending game with the facades of assurance from without and
that of a trembling little child from within.
And my life becomes a front.
And I idly chatter to you in suave tones about anything that really means nothing.
And yet I can never tell about the crying inside of me...of my greatest hurts...of my deepest
fears...my concerns.
I can't tell you that because I am afraid.
So please listen carefully not to what I am saying, but to what I am not saying.
To what I'd like to be able to say. And for what my very own survival I need to say.
I dislike this hiding...honestly.
I dislike this phony, superficial game I'm playing.
I really would like to be genuine and spontaneous and me. But you've got to help me.
You've got to hold out your hand.
You've got to hold out your hand even when it appears to you that it's the last thing I want from
you, because I am going to share a secret with you about myself;
the moment I act like I need you the least is the moment I need you the most. The moment I act like
I need you the least is the moment I need you the most.
Don't be fooled by this mask. When you see anger in this mask, don't be fooled for one
second...that's not anger, that's hurt.
The mask of anger is easier to show than the mask of hurt.
And if we make the error of looking at people's masks only to see anger on their face, we may end
up in a confrontation only because we missed the point.

You have the power to wipe away this blank stare of the "breathing dead" beneath this mask. It will
not be easy for you.
Long felt hurts make my masks endure. The nearer you approach me the harder I may strike back.
Irrationally, I fight against the very thing that I cry out for - my identity.
You may wonder who I am. You shouldn't.
Don't be fooled by the face I wear.
I am someone you know very well.
I am every man and woman and child you meet.

After reading the poem, write a 3 - 5 sentence paragraph in which you explain 1) how the poem relates to the pieces of literature we have read this six weeks, 2) the overall message or theme of the poem, and 3) how the poem personally relates to you.  YOU MUST INCLUDE SOME TYPE OF EVIDENCE FROM THE POEM IN YOUR RESPONSE.

Identity: Belonging

"Guidelines" by Lisa Suhair Majaj

If they ask you what you are,
say Arab. If they flinch, don't react,
just remember your great-aunt's eyes.

If they ask you where you come from,
say Toledo. Detroit. Mission Viejo.
Fall Springs. Topeka. If they seem confused,

help them locate these places on a map,
then inquire casually, Where are you from?
Have you been here long? Do you like this country?

If they ask you what you eat,
don't dissemble. If garlic is your secret friend,
admit it. Likewise, crab cakes.

If they say you're not American,
don't pull out your personal,
wallet-sized flag. Instead, recall

the Bill of Rights. Mention the Constitution.
Wear democracy like a favorite garment:
comfortable, intimate.

If they wave newspapers in your face and shout,
stay calm. Remember everything they never learned.
Offer to take them to the library.

If they ask you if you're white, say it depends.
Say no. Say maybe. If appropriate, inquire,
Have you always been white, or is it recent?

If you take to the streets in protest,
link hands with whomever is beside you. 
Keep your eyes on the colonizer's maps, 

geography's twisted strands, the many colors
of struggle. No matter how far you've come, remember:
the starting line is always closer than you think.

If they ask how long you plan to stay, say forever.
Console them if they seem upset. Say, don't worry,
you'll get used to it. Say, we live here. How about you?

Read the above poem written by Lisa Suhair Majaj.  After reading the poem, write a 5 - 7 sentence paragraph in which you explain 1) the tone, 2) the theme, and 3) what the poem could be saying about the American identity.  YOU MUST INCLUDE SOME TYPE OF EVIDENCE FROM THE POEM IN YOUR RESPONSE.

Identity

American Identity



Topic:  The Emerging American Identity

In one paragraph, write your thoughts about the emerging American identity in relation to the American dream. 

Cycles

Picking up chips and stacking wood,

Exactly as the old men did—

Picking up chips and stacking wood:

Is it just a vicious circle?

Wood for winter—

I’ll still be cold.

Some wine, two glasses—

I’ll still be cold…

How does this poem relate to the idea of one’s society impacting that individual?  Your response must include at least one example from A Lesson Before Dying and one example of your own personal experience. 

JUSTICE FOR ALL

Is justice always just?



Respond to the above question.  You MUST use a relevant quote that supports your response.  DO NOT USE "I" IN YOUR RESPONSE.

Who Is In Control?

Do we control the direction of our lives, or do forces outside of our control determine our destiny? 

Based upon personal experience or the experiences of others, answer the above question.  DO NOT use "I" in your response.

All For One or One For All





In a well written paragraph, answer the following questions:

• What is more important the community or the individual?  Why?
• Is order more important than freedom?  If so, when is order more important than freedom?  If not, why is freedom more important than order?

Conformity

Euripides states, "No man on earth is truly free. All are slaves of money or necessity. Public opinion or fear of prosecution forces each one, against his conscience, to conform." Do you agree or disagree with Euripides?  Why or why not?  Give specific reasons or examples.

Choices

CHOICES By Nikki Giovanni

if i can't do
what i want to do
then my job is to not
do what i don't want
to do

it's not the same thing
but it's the best i can
do

if i can't have
what i want . . . then
my job is to want
what i've got
and be satisfied
that at least there
is something more to want

since i can't go
where i need
to go . . . then i must . . . go
where the signs point
through always understanding
parallel movement
isn't lateral
when i can't express
what i really feel
i practice feeling
what i can express
and none of it is equal
i know
but that's why mankind
alone among the animals
learns to cry

Respond to the above poem.  What are your thoughts?  How does the poem speak to you?  (Key Word: CHOICES)Use lines from the poem to support your thoughts.

*Remember your username (KEwing1) and follow blogging expectations*

Deepest Fear

In the movie Coach Carter, a quote by Marianne Williamson was used by one of the players.  "Our deepest fear is not that we are inadequate. Our deepest fear is that we are powerful beyond measure. It is our light, not our darkness, that frightens us most. We ask ourselves, 'Who am I to be brilliant, gorgeous, talented, and famous?'...."  Respond to the above quote.  How does this quote relate to you or how does this quote relate to life and the individual's struggle with who they are.